Free Download
The Voice of the Underdog®
Chapter 1
The Country’s Leading Challenger Brand Agency
Updated September 2026
Let’s Connect
The LOOMIS Agency is a Dallas advertising agency that works with challenger brands. Challenger brands are the only work we do, and have been since 1984. From Dallas, we serve restaurant, franchise, healthcare, retail, and financial brands nationally.
Finding direction. Working through growing pains. Learning how to win.
Every ambitious brand reaches moments when determination alone isn’t enough.
Think about an emerging athlete with their sights set on something bigger. They surround themselves with coaches, trainers and specialists who can help them build on their strengths, overcome setbacks and keep progressing. And when they get close to the top but still can’t quite break through, they turn to people who have been there before. People who can see what they can’t, sharpen what’s already working and help them take on bigger competitors.
Challenger brands need the same kind of support.
They need a partner who understands what it takes to grow without losing what makes them different. One who can help them navigate obstacles, challenge category giants and turn potential into momentum.
That’s what a challenger brand agency is built to do.
And you’ve just found the best challenger brand agency in the country.
Welcome to the Dogfight
Since our founding more than 40+ years ago, LOOMIS has been helping challenger brands compete with category leaders and win. As an agency that works exclusively with challenger brands, we help underleveraged brands get noticed. And it all starts with a deep understanding of what it means to be the underdog.
According to current data from the Small Business & Entrepreneurship Council, out of 32.6 million businesses in the United States, only 20,868 have more than 500 employees, while 84.7 percent have fewer than 20. Clearly, we are a nation of underdogs. In every category, there is only one, on occasion two, true category leaders. That leaves the vast majority of brands in the role of challenger. But here’s the thing – being a challenger brand is about way more than just your employee count. You’ve most likely heard the quote, “It’s not the size of the dog in the fight, but the fight in the dog that matters.” Winning as a challenger brand is about mindset and action, not size. LOOMIS is the best challenger brand agency in the country because we understand that, and we help our clients leverage that truth in ways they wouldn’t see on their own.
What Makes a Challenger Brand:
The Challenger Brand Ethos
Three fundamental factors make up what we refer to as the “Challenger Brand Ethos.” It’s the starting point for every challenger brand that genuinely wants to compete.
1
State of Market
The first factor is STATE OF MARKET, understanding honestly where you rank among your competitors.
2
State of Mind
The second factor is STATE OF MIND, understanding who you are as a brand. Challenger brands are the best at something, or actively striving to be the best.
3
State of Readiness
The third factor is where the rubber meets the road and where true challengers are separated from wannabe brands forever stuck in neutral. It is the STATE OF READINESS, or put another way, understanding how prepared you are to go to battle. Are you open to new ways of thinking and potentially uncomfortable ideas? Are you open to changing things up and doing business differently? Are you ready to get out of your own way and pull the trigger to improve your ability to compete?
True challenger brands engender a corporate culture of willingness, openness, and energy for embracing new modes of thinking. This includes a higher organizational tolerance for calculated risk-taking. Often, this culture is present early in a company’s lifecycle but may wane as the company matures, and modes of thinking become traditionalized. It can be reignited during an organizational inflection point, such as a leadership change, or a reengineering process that has been intentionally and effectively managed. But regardless of origin, the company’s collective mindset must embrace alternative ideas. It’s the strategy behind, and creative implementation of those ideas that make LOOMIS the country’s leading challenger brand agency.
Which Kind of Agency Does
a Challenger Brand Need?
Ask four agencies what a challenger brand needs, and you will get four answers that happen to match their area of focus.
The branding shop says you need positioning. The creative shop says you need a big idea. The PR firm says you need credibility. The performance shop says you need better targeting. None of them are wrong. Each of them zeroes in on one piece of a problem that does not come apart cleanly.
Here is what usually happens. A challenger brand hires a branding agency and gets a positioning deck. That deck goes to an ad agency, which reinterprets it creatively. The campaign goes to a PR firm, which softens it. The whole thing lands with a performance shop, which optimizes the softened version for cost per click. Four vendors, four interpretations. By the time the work reaches the market, the distinction that justified the entire exercise has been sanded off.
Category leaders can absorb that. They have the budget to pay for the same thinking four times over and the market position to survive a diluted message. Challengers do not. When you are the third brand in your category, a diluted message is not a missed opportunity. It is a paid reminder that the leader exists. And is winning.
So the useful question is not which type of agency do you need. It is in recognizing what purposes each type serves, and what happens at the seams between them.
Brand strategy / branding
What it owns: The position
A challenger needs it when The market cannot say why you and not them
Where it breaks The deck never reaches the work
Advertising / creative
What it owns: The idea
A challenger needs it when The position is real and needs to be felt
Where it breaks Instinct to stay in safe territory
PR / communications
What it owns: The proof
A challenger needs it when The claim is bold enough to need backing
Where it breaks Coverage that reinforces nothing
Digital / SEO / content
What it owns: The capture
A challenger needs it when Demand exists and needs converting
Where it breaks Efficiency on an undifferentiated message
| Agency type | What it owns | A challenger needs it when | Where it breaks |
|---|---|---|---|
| Brand strategy / branding | The position | The market cannot say why you and not them | The deck never reaches the work |
| Advertising / creative | The idea | The position is real and needs to be felt | Instinct to stay in safe territory |
| PR / communications | The proof | The claim is bold enough to need backing | Coverage that reinforces nothing |
| Digital / SEO / content | The capture | Demand exists and needs converting | Efficiency on an undifferentiated message |
Look at the four failure points together and the pattern is hard to miss.
Every one of them happens at a handoff.
Every one of them happens at a handoff.
That is the argument for holding positioning, creative, media, and digital in the same building, and it is the reason LOOMIS is built the way it is. Not because integration is fashionable. Because a challenger brand cannot afford to have its distinction renegotiated four times before it reaches a customer.
One more thing is worth saying plainly. The type of agency matters less than whether you matter to the agency. At the wrong shop, your account is the fifth most important thing happening on a Tuesday, and accounts like that get junior teams. Ask anyone you are considering where your business would rank in their book, and who would still be in the room a year after the pitch. The answer will tell you more than the credentials deck.
Restaurant + Franchise + Healthcare + Retail
Who We Work With
Restaurant and QSR
This is the category where a challenger’s disadvantage is most visible, because the leader’s sign is on the next corner.
We have worked with Golden Chick since 2014, when the brand had 103 units. It is well past 200 today, with average unit volume doubled systemwide. Texas Dairy Queen, Black Bear Diner, Rib Crib, and Taco Bueno have all trusted us with work that had to move traffic, not just win awards. We did both.
Franchise
Franchise brands carry an added complication most challengers do not. Every message has to work for the consumer and for the franchisee, and those two audiences do not always want the same thing.
We have built systemwide campaigns that franchisees actually adopt, which is a different discipline from building campaigns that test well at corporate.
Healthcare
Challenger brands in the healthcare space compete on trust, something that cannot be bought with frequency.
Texas Oncology and Texas Colon & Rectal Specialists have both engaged us for work in categories where the wrong tone does more damage than no advertising at all.
Retail and Consumer Services
Fitness Connection. Sun Tan City. Rug Doctor. The Maids. Stanley Steemer. Murphy USA.
Different businesses, same problem. This is a commoditized category where the customer sees very little difference between options and defaults to whichever brand is cheapest or closest. Our job is to give them a third reason.
What these challenger brands have in common is not size or category. It’s a posture.
Every one of them arrived understanding that they were not going to win by doing a slightly better version of what the leader was already doing. That understanding is the only real prerequisite for working with us. We can build the strategy and make the work. We cannot install the willingness to be different, and we have learned the hard way not to take on brands that are hoping we will.
7 Reasons to Choose LOOMIS
Every advertising agency will tell you they have what it takes to help challenger brands win. Very few have wholly committed themselves to making challenger brand success their exclusive focus. More than 20 years ago, that’s exactly what LOOMIS did. There’s not an agency in the country that wouldn’t love to have Coca-Cola, GEICO, Nike, Home Depot, and Ford on their rosters. But corporate monoliths like those aren’t who we serve. We fight with the brands that break themselves against the category leaders again and again and again, chipping away and finding victory in unexpected places. We’ve helped brands win that fight for nearly four decades and we can do the same for you. Here are seven reasons why.
1
Our Purpose
We are a challenger brand agency. Period. We understand challenger brands because we’re an underdog ourselves. We aren’t the biggest, or the most famous. But, you ought to see us in a dogfight. We have fully embraced our purpose: to “help underdogs win.” It’s not an area of expertise or one bullet point in a long list of capabilities on our website. Helping challenger brands win is all we do.
2
Our People
Of all the things we’re proudest of, our people top the list. Our award-winning staff includes more than 70 industry experts who specialize in marketing and advertising strategy, account service, creative, media, digital marketing, and more. We’re perpetually included on multiple “Best Places To Work” lists. And, on average over the past 20 years, we’ve held on to our talent twice as long as the national average. There are several reasons for that, but one of the biggest is how compelling it is to work for a challenger brand agency focused on creating and implementing big ideas that move the needle for our clients. It takes a special mindset to thrive here. Our people are smart, brave, and driven, with an unmatched work ethic. Our team is fiercely loyal to our clients, to the agency, and to each other. It’s no coincidence that our client tenure also vastly exceeds the national average.
3
Our Book
When we say we wrote the book on challenger branding and culture, we mean it literally. Published in 2020, “The Voice of the Underdog: How Challenger Brands Create Distinction By Thinking Culture First” is a master class on how to compete as a challenger brand, and the importance of building an extraordinary company culture. Written by LOOMIS CEO, Mike Sullivan and Michael Tuggle, the former co-Executive Creative Director at LOOMIS, the book unpacks the poorly understood and grossly underleveraged connection between brand and culture. Filled with fascinating case studies, entertaining stories, and engaging insights, the book examines the true essence of what makes a company a challenger brand, unveils how successful challengers of all sizes use culture to create extraordinary brand distinction, and finishes with a detailed blueprint for building your own transcendent culture.
4
Our Training
Like any great athlete, we don’t just show up and perform. We train. We study. We watch, listen, learn, read, and discuss challenger branding strategies, tactics, and ideas all the time. Challenger branding is a living, breathing, evolving process and as the leading challenger brand agency, we have to change with it. We are lifelong learners who are open to new ways of thinking and believe that creative ideas can come from anywhere. We train hard to be the best at what we do.
5
Our Process
As part of our Challenger Brand Workshop Series, we developed “The Challenger Blueprint: A Systematic Guide for Building the Underdog That Wins.” It’s a proprietary process that helps us identify where a challenger brand is in its journey, what they need to do to compete, and what the consumer insights are to drive that growth. The result is a marketing and advertising plan grounded in the Challenger Brand Ethos that’s laser-focused and primed for competition. Our success as a challenger brand agency and that of our clients starts with this process.
6
Our Structure
Above, we posit that challenger brands lose their distinction when handoffs happen. Fair, then, to ask how we are built to avoid them. Strategy, creative, media, digital, and social all sit under this roof and answer to the same work. The design firm is in-house and has the awards to justify being there rather than on a vendor list. We have direct access to one of the best recording studios in the country, and an inside track to Grammy-winning engineers and composers who can produce original audio quickly.
Performance measurement is ours too. When the team that made the work also owns the numbers, nobody gets to blame the media plan for weak creative, or the creative for weak targeting. None of this is unusual at a large agency, but it is for an agency our size. That’s the entire point. You get the benefits of a big agency partner without becoming a line item in someone’s quarterly forecast.
7
Our Results
That brings us to the thing you likely care about the most – results. We wouldn’t be America’s leading challenger brand agency without them. Quite frankly, at LOOMIS we are obsessed with moving the needle for our clients. We drive revenue. We sell tickets. We put butts in seats.
- We helped double the Average Unit Volume of a 600-store QSR chain.
- We helped increase the profit of a home services company five-fold over eight years.
- We created a national sports promotion of the year for a pizza chain, a promotion so successful when it ran that competitors told their delivery drivers to stay at home.
- We helped increase the web traffic for a healthcare company by 44 percent and new patient requests by 36 percent in one year.
- During COVID, we helped a 200-unit QSR chain increase their Nation’s Restaurant News ranking by 43 spots.
Those are just a few of our success stories, but they should give you some idea of what it’s like to work with LOOMIS. We aren’t a challenger brand agency because we choose to position ourselves that way. We’re the country’s leading challenger brand agency because nobody understands challenger brands and how to help them win better than we do. If you’re a challenger brand, you’ll find no greater advocate. Call us and let us show you.
Frequently Asked Questions
Most full-service agencies are built to protect a position. We are built to take one. That difference shows up in the work long before it shows up in a credentials deck. A leader’s agency optimizes for reach and consistency, because the brand is already the default and the job is to stay there. A challenger’s agency optimizes for distinction, because sounding like the leader means you just paid to remind the market that the leader exists. Same channels. Opposite instincts.
Yes, in fact, some of the best ones are. Challenger is a posture, not a market share number. A brand can lead its category and still behave like a challenger, and those are the hardest brands in the world to compete against, because they have the resources of an incumbent and the instincts of an underdog. The reverse is just as common. Plenty of small brands behave exactly like the leader they are trying to unseat, then wonder why nothing moves.
Yes. We are headquartered in Dallas and work with regional and national brands across the country. Being in Dallas matters if you want people in the room for strategy sessions, production, and the meetings that go sideways. Plenty of our clients want exactly that. It has never determined who we take on.
The Challenger Blueprint is our proprietary process, built out of our internal 16-week Challenger Brand Workshop Series. It identifies where a brand actually sits in its journey, what it must do to compete, and which consumer insight should drive growth. The output is a marketing and advertising plan grounded in the Challenger Brand Ethos rather than in whatever the category has decided is normal.
LOOMIS is a leading challenger brand advertising agency based in Dallas, specializing in campaign development, digital, social, mobile, and user experience. As part of Meet The People, an international network of independently operated agencies, LOOMIS offers clients access to specialized talent, technology, and capabilities across the network.
